There is much introspection and navel-gazing in the world of user experience design. More than usual, I mean.
Jesse James Garrett recently said:
I don’t think I know anyone that’s been in UX more than a decade who’s happy with how it’s going.
Mark Hurst wrote Why I'm losing faith in UX. Too hot!
Scott Berkun wrote How To Put Faith in Design. Too cold!
Peter Merholz wrote Waking up from the dream of UX. Just right!
As an aside, does it bother anyone else that the Goldilocks story violates the laws of thermodynamics?
Anyway, this hand-wringing around the role of UX today seemed like a suitably hot topic for one of our regular roundtable chats at Clearleft. We invited Peter along too and he was kind enough to give us his time.
It was a fun discussion. Peter pointed out that whenever he hears an older designer bemoaning the current state of design, he has to wonder what’s happened in their lives to make them feel that way (it’s like when people complain about the music of today and how it’s not as good as the music of whatever time period I was a teenager). And let’s face it, the good ol’ days weren’t so good for everyone. It was overwhelmingly dominated by privileged white dudes. The more that changes, the better ...and it needs to change far, far more.
There was a general agreement that the current gnashing of teeth isn’t unique to UX. It’s something that just about any discipline will inevitably go through. Peter’s epiphany was to compare it with the hand-wringing around Agile:
The frustration exhibited with the "dream of UX" is (I think) identical to the frustration the original Agile community sees with how it has been industrialized (koff-SAFe-koff).
Perhaps the industrialisation of what once a cottage industry is the price of success. But that’s not necessarily bad, as long as you industrialise the right things. If UX has become the churning out of wireframes at scale, then something has gone very wrong. If UX has become the implementation of dark patterns at scale, then something has gone very wrong.
In some organisations, perhaps that’s exactly what’s happened. In which case, I can totally understand the disillusionment. But in other places, I see the opposite happening. I see UX designers bringing questions of ethics to the forefront. I see UX designers—dare I say it?—having their proverbial seat at the table.
Chris went so far as to claim that we are in fact in a golden age of user experience design. Controversial! But think about it, he said. Over the next few days, pay attention to interactions you have with technology, and consider the thought and skill that has gone into them.
I had Chris’s provocation in mind when I wrote about booking my vaccination appointment:
I just need to get in, accomplish my task, and get out again. This is where the World Wide Web shines.
Maybe Chris is right. Maybe the golden age of UX is here. It’s just not evenly distributed. Yet.
It’s an interesting time for the discipline of user experience design. I’ve always maintained that the best way to get a temperature check for your chosen field is to go to a really good conference. If you’re a UX designer and you want to understand the state of the UX nation, you should get a ticket for the online UX Fest in June. See you there!
This was originally posted on my own site.